All Flavors
$ 7.99
$ 6.99
Original Toffee Covered Pretzels
$ 17.99
$ 15.99
Birthday Cake Toffee
$ 7.99
$ 6.99
Maple Brown Butter Toffee Covered Pretzels
$ 17.99
$ 15.99
Cinnamon French Toast
$ 18.99
$ 16.99
Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Pistachio
$ 17.99
$ 15.99
Cookies and Cream
$ 25.97
3 Pack Gift Set
$ 7.99
$ 6.99
Vanilla Toffee Covered Pretzels
$ 18.99
$ 16.99
Key Lime Pie Toffee
$ 51.99
$ 39.00
Insurrection Collection
$ 18.99
$ 15.99
Mitch McCaramel Turtle Pecan Toffee
$ 49.00
$ 39.00
Jimothy Crunch - Toffee of the Week
$ 49.00
$ 39.00
Orange Creamsicle - Toffee of the Week
$ 49.00
$ 39.00